PhysicsClassical Physics

Is a Collision Elastic When They Stick Together? Asteroid Example

The two asteroids undergo a perfectly inelastic collision. Add their momentum components to find a combined speed of about 900 m/s at 12.8° toward the second asteroid’s incoming direction.

Question

Two asteroids merge when they collide. Asteroid 1 has mass 15 × 10³ kg and initial speed 770 m/s. Asteroid 2 has mass 20 × 10³ kg and initial speed 1020 m/s. The angle between their incoming velocity vectors is 20°. Determine the speed of the combined object and its direction relative to asteroid 1’s initial velocity.

Collision type

No. Sticking together makes this a perfectly inelastic collision. Momentum is conserved for the asteroid pair when the external impulse during impact is negligible. Kinetic energy is not conserved for these distinct incoming velocities.

Choose axes without inventing a compass direction

Take +x along asteroid 1’s incoming velocity and choose +y toward the side on which asteroid 2’s incoming velocity lies. Then

v⃗1=(770,0)  m/s,v⃗2=(1020cos⁡20∘,1020sin⁡20∘)  m/s.\vec v_1=(770,0)\;\mathrm{m/s},\qquad \vec v_2=(1020\cos20^\circ,1020\sin20^\circ)\;\mathrm{m/s}.

The final mass is 15,000 + 20,000 = 35,000 kg. Both asteroids share one final velocity because they merge.

Conserve each momentum component

vf,x=15000(770)+20000(1020)cos⁡20∘35000=877.7066  m/s,v_{f,x}=\frac{15000(770)+20000(1020)\cos20^\circ}{35000} =877.7066\;\mathrm{m/s}, vf,y=20000(1020)sin⁡20∘35000=199.3489  m/s.v_{f,y}=\frac{20000(1020)\sin20^\circ}{35000} =199.3489\;\mathrm{m/s}.

Final speed and direction

vf=vf,x2+vf,y2=900.0604  m/s≈900  m/s,v_f=\sqrt{v_{f,x}^2+v_{f,y}^2} =900.0604\;\mathrm{m/s}\approx900\;\mathrm{m/s}, ϕ=atan2⁡(vf,y,vf,x)=12.7962∘≈12.8∘.\phi=\operatorname{atan2}(v_{f,y},v_{f,x}) =12.7962^\circ\approx12.8^\circ.

The combined asteroid travels at about 900 m/s, at 12.8° from asteroid 1’s initial direction toward asteroid 2’s initial direction. If the second velocity is drawn below the x-axis, the y-component and signed angle reverse; the speed and the angle between the relevant directions do not change.

Energy check of the collision classification

This check supports the keyword’s elastic-versus-sticking question; the original numerical task asks for speed and direction.

Ki=12(15000)(770)2+12(20000)(1020)2=1.485075×1010  J,K_i=\tfrac12(15000)(770)^2+\tfrac12(20000)(1020)^2 =1.485075\times10^{10}\;\mathrm J, Kf=12(35000)(900.0604)2≈1.4176904×1010  J.K_f=\tfrac12(35000)(900.0604)^2 \approx1.4176904\times10^{10}\;\mathrm J.

The kinetic-energy decrease is approximately 6.74 × 10⁸ J, or 4.54%. That energy is transferred to other forms, such as deformation and internal energy; total energy is not destroyed. Do not impose an elastic kinetic-energy equation on a sticking collision.

Evidence boundary

This answer uses the masses, speeds, 20° inter-velocity angle, and sticking condition in OpenStax University Physics Volume 1, Chapter 9, Problem 56. Only a relative direction is specified, so the selected y-axis is a coordinate convention rather than an added compass direction. External impulse during the brief collision is neglected. Extra calculator digits document the calculation and do not assert extra measurement precision.

Sources

These references support the concepts and methods used in the explanation above.