Question
Differentiate the hyperbolic cosine function with respect to , and check the real domains.
Domain first
The real square root requires . Since hyperbolic cosine accepts every real argument, the function domain is .
Differentiate on the interior
For , put . Then
Therefore
The derivative of has a positive sign. The negative derivative rule for ordinary cosine does not apply here.
What happens at the endpoint?
The displayed derivative formula is undefined at , although . A usual two-sided derivative of this real-domain function is not defined at that endpoint because the function has no real values for .
If a right-hand derivative is requested, compute it separately. With ,
Here follows from the derivative of at zero. Thus the original exercise's interior derivative has domain ; the endpoint value refers specifically to a right-hand derivative, not to substituting zero into that formula.
Evidence boundary
This page solves the independently selected Exercise 9(b) in the University of Melbourne bridging notes over the real numbers. The printed answer gives the interior formula for x > 0. The endpoint right-hand derivative is a separately derived clarification, not an extra instruction attributed to the worksheet or a two-sided derivative of the given real-domain function.
Sources
These references support the concepts and methods used in the explanation above.