PhysicsClassical Physics

Tension Is a Force: A Ball in an Accelerating Freight Car

Calculate freight-car acceleration and string tension for a 20.0 g ball inclined 35.0° from vertical, using the horizontal and vertical components of tension.

Question

A 20.0-g ball hangs from the roof of a freight car by a string. When the freight car begins to move, the string makes an angle of 35.0° with the vertical.(a) What is the acceleration of the freight car?(b) What is the tension in the string?

What forces act on the ball?

Tension is a pulling force exerted by the string along the string. On the ball it points upward toward the roof attachment, with a horizontal component in the direction of the car’s acceleration. Gravity points downward.

Convert the mass first:

m=20.0 g=0.0200 kg,mg=(0.0200)(9.80)=0.196 N.m=20.0\,\mathrm{g}=0.0200\,\mathrm{kg},\qquad mg=(0.0200)(9.80)=0.196\,\mathrm{N}.

Use an inertial frame, positive horizontal along the car’s acceleration and positive vertical upward. In the textbook’s steady-deflection model, the ball shares the car’s horizontal acceleration and has ay=0a_y=0. With the string 35.0∘35.0^\circ from the vertical,

Tsin⁡35.0∘=ma,Tcos⁡35.0∘−mg=0.T\sin35.0^\circ=ma,\qquad T\cos35.0^\circ-mg=0.

These are the components of one tension force. Do not add a separate “horizontal tension” as another independent force, and do not add a fictitious force to these inertial-frame equations.

(a) Acceleration of the freight car

Divide the horizontal equation by the vertical support equation to eliminate both TT and mm:

tan⁡35.0∘=mamg=ag.\tan35.0^\circ=\frac{ma}{mg}=\frac{a}{g}.

Therefore

a=gtan⁡35.0∘=(9.80)(0.700208)=6.86203 m/s2≈6.86 m/s2.a=g\tan35.0^\circ=(9.80)(0.700208) =6.86203\,\mathrm{m/s^2} \approx\boxed{6.86\,\mathrm{m/s^2}}.

The acceleration is horizontal, toward the side to which the tension’s horizontal component points. The ball hangs backward relative to that acceleration direction. The statement supplies no absolute compass direction.

(b) Tension in the string

The vertical component alone supports the weight:

T=mgcos⁡35.0∘=0.1960.819152=0.239272 N≈0.239 N.T=\frac{mg}{\cos35.0^\circ} =\frac{0.196}{0.819152} =0.239272\,\mathrm{N} \approx\boxed{0.239\,\mathrm{N}}.

The full tension is greater than the weight because part of it produces horizontal acceleration.

Check

The unrounded tension gives Tcos⁡35∘=0.196 NT\cos35^\circ=0.196\,\mathrm{N} and Tsin⁡35∘=0.137241 N=maT\sin35^\circ=0.137241\,\mathrm{N}=ma. The vertical net force is zero while the horizontal net force is not. A fixed angle inside an accelerating car does not mean zero acceleration in the ground frame.

Evidence boundary

The data are from OpenStax University Physics Volume 1, Chapter 6, Problem 38. The solution uses the textbook’s steady-deflection model: the ball remains at a fixed angle relative to the accelerating car, with no vertical acceleration, and g = 9.80 m/s². An instantaneous angle during free oscillation would not by itself determine the car acceleration. No transient motion or measured data are supplied.

Sources

Эти источники подтверждают изложенные выше концепции и методы.