PhysicsClassical Physics

What Is Newton's 3rd Law? Forces on a Hand-Held Coffee Cup

Identify the forces on a supported coffee cup and place each third-law partner on the other interacting object.

Question

Suppose that you are holding a cup of coffee in your hand. Identify all forces on the cup and the reaction to each force.

Answer

Newton's third law says that interacting objects exert equal-magnitude, opposite-direction forces on each other. For the held cup, each partner acts on another object, not on the cup again.

Forces on the cup and their partners

Treat “cup” literally as the container, distinct from the coffee inside. For a cup held still, neglecting small air effects:

Force acting on the cupThird-law partnerObject receiving the partner
Earth's gravitational pull downwardThe cup's gravitational pull on Earth, directed toward the cupEarth
The hand's upward supporting contact forceThe cup's downward contact force on the handHand
The coffee's downward contact load on the cupThe cup's upward supporting contact force on the coffeeCoffee

The hand entry is the resultant supporting contact force. If the cup is gripped at the side, that resultant can include friction and normal contact forces; the problem does not prescribe a grip geometry.

Why the cup stays still

For the container alone, vertical equilibrium gives

Fhand on cup−mcupg−Fcoffee on cup=0.F_{\mathrm{hand\ on\ cup}}-m_{\mathrm{cup}}g-F_{\mathrm{coffee\ on\ cup}}=0.

These are forces on one body whose resultant is zero. Their balance is an equilibrium condition, not a third-law pairing.

If “cup of coffee” means cup plus contents

For that combined system, the cup–coffee contact pair is internal. The principal external forces are the hand's support upward and Earth's gravity downward:

Fhand=(mcup+mcoffee)g.F_{\mathrm{hand}}=(m_{\mathrm{cup}}+m_{\mathrm{coffee}})g.

The corresponding partners act on the hand and Earth. The upward support and downward weight on the combined system are still not each other's third-law partners, even though they balance.

Evidence boundary

This answers Chapter 5 Conceptual Question 12. No masses or force magnitudes are supplied, so the answer identifies interactions symbolically. The container and cup-plus-coffee interpretations are stated explicitly. It uses the standard stationary, supported-cup model and neglects small atmospheric effects; the hand contact is a resultant, not an assumed grip geometry.

Sources

Các nguồn này hỗ trợ những khái niệm và phương pháp được giải thích ở trên.