MathCalculus

Calculus Theorems: Why the Mean Value Theorem Fails at a Corner

Prove that the derivative never matches the secant slope for a shifted absolute-value function, and identify the failed Mean Value Theorem hypothesis.

Question

For

f(x)=∣x−12∣,f(x)=\left|x-\frac12\right|,

show that no cc in (−1,1)(-1,1) satisfies

f(1)−f(−1)=2f′(c).f(1)-f(-1)=2f'(c).

Explain why the Mean Value Theorem does not apply on [−1,1][-1,1].

No such cc exists

For f(x)=∣x−1/2∣f(x)=|x-1/2| on [−1,1][-1,1], the Mean Value Theorem cannot be applied because ff is not differentiable at the interior point x=1/2x=1/2.

1. Compute the endpoint difference and secant slope

f(1)=12,f(−1)=32,f(1)−f(−1)=−1.f(1)=\frac12,\qquad f(-1)=\frac32,\qquad f(1)-f(-1)=-1.

The secant slope is

f(1)−f(−1)1−(−1)=−12.\frac{f(1)-f(-1)}{1-(-1)}=-\frac12.

Consequently, the requested equation f(1)−f(−1)=2f′(c)f(1)-f(-1)=2f'(c) would require f′(c)=−1/2f'(c)=-1/2.

2. Check every possible interior point

The piecewise function and derivative are

f(x)={12−x,x<12,x−12,x≥12,f(x)=\begin{cases}\frac12-x,&x<\frac12,\\x-\frac12,&x\ge\frac12,\end{cases} f′(x)={−1,x<12,1,x>12.f'(x)=\begin{cases}-1,&x<\frac12,\\1,&x>\frac12.\end{cases}

For −1<c<1/2-1<c<1/2, 2f′(c)=−22f'(c)=-2, which is not the endpoint difference −1-1. For 1/2<c<11/2<c<1, 2f′(c)=22f'(c)=2, also not −1-1.

At c=1/2c=1/2, the left derivative is −1-1 and the right derivative is 11, so f′(1/2)f'(1/2) does not exist. This point cannot satisfy an equation involving its derivative.

These three cases exhaust (−1,1)(-1,1). Hence no cc satisfies the required equation.

3. Identify the exact failed hypothesis

The Mean Value Theorem requires continuity on the whole closed interval and differentiability at every point of the open interval. Absolute value is continuous, so continuity on [−1,1][-1,1] holds. Differentiability fails at 1/2∈(−1,1)1/2\in(-1,1).

The corner prevents the theorem's guarantee. It does not contradict the theorem, whose hypotheses are not satisfied. The direct derivative check above proves the stronger statement needed here: in this particular exercise, a matching cc actually does not exist.

Evidence boundary

This solution addresses OpenStax Calculus Volume 1 section 4.4, exercise 167, with f(x) = |x − 1/2| on [−1,1]. The no-c conclusion follows from the exact derivative values and the undefined derivative at the corner. It is not inferred merely from failure of a theorem hypothesis.

Sources

Các nguồn này hỗ trợ những khái niệm và phương pháp được giải thích ở trên.