PhysicsClassical Physics

Knowledge guide

Inelastic Collisions in Two Dimensions: Momentum and Energy Checks

Use separate momentum-component equations for objects that merge, recover final speed and direction, and use a relative-velocity energy identity to distinguish sticking from elastic collision.

Sticking selects a perfectly inelastic model

An elastic collision preserves total kinetic energy. If two bodies stick and share one final velocity, their collision is perfectly inelastic. Momentum conservation depends on the external impulse on the selected system, not on whether the collision is elastic.

For a brief impact, neglecting external impulse may be a useful approximation. State that assumption rather than claiming that every pair of colliding objects is automatically isolated.

Add vectors before calculating speed

For two merging masses,

v⃗f=m1v⃗1+m2v⃗2m1+m2.\vec v_f=\frac{m_1\vec v_1+m_2\vec v_2}{m_1+m_2}.

Write this separately for x and y. Then find speed from the magnitude and direction from atan2⁡(vf,y,vf,x)\operatorname{atan2}(v_{f,y},v_{f,x}). Adding incoming speeds as scalars fails when the velocity directions differ. The returned angle must be interpreted with respect to the axes you actually chose.

An independent cart example

On a frictionless horizontal platform, a 1 kg cart moving at (6, 0) m/s merges with a 2 kg cart moving at (0, 3) m/s. Their total momentum is (6, 6) kg·m/s, and their combined mass is 3 kg:

v⃗f=(2,2)  m/s,∣v⃗f∣=22  m/s,ϕ=45∘.\vec v_f=(2,2)\;\mathrm{m/s},\quad |\vec v_f|=2\sqrt2\;\mathrm{m/s},\quad \phi=45^\circ.

Initially, K = 18 + 9 = 27 J. Finally, K = ½(3)(2² + 2²) = 12 J. The 15 J difference becomes other forms of energy. Some kinetic energy remains because the total momentum is not zero.

An energy identity that works in any dimension

Expanding the initial and final kinetic energies gives

Ki−Kf=12m1m2m1+m2∣v⃗1−v⃗2∣2.K_i-K_f=\frac12\frac{m_1m_2}{m_1+m_2} |\vec v_1-\vec v_2|^2.

For the carts, the reduced mass is 2/3 kg and the squared relative speed is 45 m²/s², giving 15 J again. The result is nonnegative and is positive when their incoming velocities differ. It depends on their relative velocity, so a Galilean change of reference frame does not change this loss.

For fixed total mass and momentum, the common-velocity state has the least kinetic energy. This explains the word “perfectly”; it does not mean that all initial kinetic energy vanishes. The zero-relative-speed case makes the expression zero, but does not describe an ordinary approaching impact.

Check the result

Multiply each final velocity component by the combined mass and compare it with the corresponding initial momentum sum. Then check the kinetic-energy difference. A shared final velocity and a positive energy decrease are consistent with a sticking collision; imposing elastic energy conservation would contradict that model.

Related question

Apply this knowledge

Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.

Is a Collision Elastic When They Stick Together? Asteroid Example

Sources

These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.