First count the electrons
A hydrogen-like atom or ion has exactly one electron. For a positive ion with atomic number Z and charge +q, the electron count is Z − q. The condition for the simple one-electron formula is therefore Z − q = 1.
The quantity Z is nuclear charge in units of the elementary charge. It is not the ion’s net charge. Electron–electron interactions are absent in a one-electron system, which is why the nuclear Coulomb attraction can be treated directly.
Use the same transition before comparing species
In the basic Bohr approximation,
For the same initial and final n, photon energy scales as Z². Since wavelength is inversely proportional to photon energy, wavelength scales as 1/Z². Different transitions cannot be compared using the Z² factor alone.
New example: Be³⁺, n = 4 to n = 3
Beryllium has Z = 4. Be³⁺ contains 4 − 3 = 1 electron. With k = 2.179 × 10⁻¹⁸ J,
The corresponding hydrogen transition has energy 7k/144, approximately 1.059 × 10⁻¹⁹ J. Their ratio is 16, as the nuclear-charge scaling predicts.
Check for one electron, a positive emitted energy, and a matching transition. This is a textbook approximation: reduced-mass and precision spectral corrections are outside it, and replacing Z with an arbitrary effective charge does not make it exact for many-electron atoms.
Related question
Apply this knowledge
Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.
Atomic Structure with Bohr: He⁺ Photon Energy for n = 5 to n = 2Sources
These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.