Convert the equation, not just a point
Cylindrical coordinates use with and
Replace each occurrence consistently. Keep unchanged. If the resulting equation has no , every allowed horizontal point extends along a vertical line, producing a surface invariant under vertical translation.
A new example and the axis issue
Consider . Substitution gives
For this yields . With the usual nonnegative radius, that representation uses . The factored equation also allows for every azimuth; all of those coordinate triples describe the same physical -axis.
Dividing by is therefore not an equivalence of all coordinate triples. In this example the simplified equation still covers the physical axis at or . State whether you mean equal coordinate solution sets or the same geometric surface.
Completing the square gives : a radius- circular cylinder centered on the vertical line , . This checks the conversion without relying on a sketch.
Distinguish the two radial distances
The cylindrical radius is the distance to the -axis, . The distance to the origin is . Confusing them turns a cylinder into a sphere or changes a surface equation.
For example, becomes , not . The latter describes a cylinder, whereas the original equation describes a sphere.
Check the transformed surface
Substitute the identities back into the final equation and check any factors you divided out. Specify angle restrictions if you solve explicitly for a nonnegative radius. A polynomial equation in and trigonometric functions is often a clearer complete answer than a simplified form that hides an exceptional case.
Related question
Apply this knowledge
Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.
Cylindrical Coordinate System: Convert a Shifted Cylinder EquationSources
These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.