ChemistryGeneral Chemistry

Knowledge guide

How Valence Electron Counts Decide Lewis Dot Symbols for Atoms and Monatomic Ions

A Lewis dot symbol shows one dot per valence electron, so the group number sets the dot count for a neutral main-group atom and the electron gain or loss sets it for a monatomic ion.

Why valence electrons are the only ones drawn

Electrons in filled inner shells are not involved in the electron transfer that forms a monatomic ion, so a Lewis dot symbol ignores them. What it draws is the valence shell: the outermost electrons of a main-group atom, the ones that can be gained, lost or shared. For s- and p-block elements the count of those electrons equals the group number read in the usual way — one for group 1, two for group 2, and eight minus the group's distance from the noble gas for the p-block.

A Lewis dot symbol is therefore a symbol, not a picture of orbitals: the element's symbol stands for the nucleus and the inner electrons, and each dot stands for one valence electron. Dots are placed singly on the four sides before any pairing, but for a monatomic ion only the total count carries chemical meaning.

Cations: electrons are removed

Main-group metals reach a noble-gas configuration by losing valence electrons, so their ions are drawn with fewer dots than the atom:

  • Lithium, group 1, has one valence electron. Li+\mathrm{Li^+} is written with no dots and a single positive charge.
  • Barium, group 2, has two. Ba2+\mathrm{Ba^{2+}} is written with no dots and a 2+2+ charge.
  • Aluminium, group 13, has three valence electrons. Al3+\mathrm{Al^{3+}} is written with no dots and a 3+3+ charge.

An immediate consequence: the usual cations of groups 1, 2 and 13 are drawn with no dots at all. Their valence shell is empty. A structure that still shows dots on Na+\mathrm{Na^+}, Ca2+\mathrm{Ca^{2+}} or Al3+\mathrm{Al^{3+}} is wrong even if the charge is written correctly.

Anions: electrons are added until the octet closes

Nonmetals gain electrons until the valence shell holds eight, so their ions are drawn with a complete octet:

  • Oxygen, group 16, has six valence electrons. Adding two gives the oxide ion O2−\mathrm{O^{2-}}, drawn with eight dots.
  • Sulfur, group 16, behaves the same way: S2−\mathrm{S^{2-}} carries eight dots.
  • Iodine, group 17, has seven valence electrons. Adding one gives I−\mathrm{I^-}, also drawn with eight dots.

Because every one of these anions has eight dots, the charge is the only feature that distinguishes one from another, and it must always be shown.

The three features a valid ion symbol needs

  1. The right number of dots. Count the valence electrons of the neutral atom, then apply the electron gain or loss. Groups 1, 2 and 13 cations end with zero dots; group 15–17 anions end with eight.
  2. A charge that matches the electron change. One electron gained is 1−1-, two lost is 2+2+. A symbol with the right dots and no charge is incomplete, and a charge that does not match the dot count is contradictory.
  3. Brackets when a charge is shown. A charged monatomic species is enclosed in square brackets with the charge outside, so that the charge cannot be read as belonging to only part of the symbol.

A useful check is to ask what neutral atom the ion is isoelectronic with. Al3+\mathrm{Al^{3+}}, O2−\mathrm{O^{2-}}, F−\mathrm{F^-} and Mg2+\mathrm{Mg^{2+}} all end up with the electron count of neon, which is exactly why their Lewis symbols look the way they do: the metal ions show nothing in the valence shell, and the nonmetal ions show a closed octet.

Related question

Apply this knowledge

Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.

Select the Atoms or Ions with Valid Lewis Dot Structures: Cl, Na, Mg, Ca, K, Br, Sr, and F

Sources

These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.