NursingNursing Fundamentals

Therapeutic Communication: Clarifying Mr. Padilla’s Response

Compare four nursing responses and learn why asking Mr. Padilla to clarify an ambiguous statement is the therapeutic choice.

Question

Mr. Padilla is a 62-year-old male patient. The nurse goes to give him medication and asks him how he is doing. Mr. Padilla responds, “Well, my head is all messed up since they gave me those test results yesterday.” What would be a therapeutic response from the nurse?

A. “Oh, I’m sure everything is going to be okay! Why don’t you call your wife?”

B. “Have you tried distracting yourself? You could watch TV or do some exercises.”

C. “Did you not sleep very well last night?”

D. “I’m sorry, but I don’t understand what you mean. Can you explain?”

Answer

D. “I’m sorry, but I don’t understand what you mean. Can you explain?” is the therapeutic response among the four choices.

The phrase “my head is all messed up” is ambiguous. The nurse should ask Mr. Padilla to explain his meaning before assuming what he feels or what problem he is describing. Option D uses clarification, acknowledges that the nurse has not yet understood, and invites the patient to continue in his own words.

Why the other responses are less appropriate

OptionProblem in this conversation
APromises that everything will be okay without knowing the test results or the patient’s concern, then redirects him to his wife. This can close down exploration.
BSuggests coping activities before understanding what is troubling him. The suggestions do not clarify his statement.
CAssumes poor sleep is the relevant issue. Nothing in the question establishes a sleep problem.

Clarification lets the patient supply the missing meaning. It does not establish that he has confusion, insomnia, depression, or a particular diagnosis. Once he explains, the nurse can respond to the actual concern and assess any clinical problem that emerges.

Evidence boundary

This is the four-option Mr. Padilla question from OpenStax Clinical Nursing Skills, Chapter 3, Review Question 4. The prompt gives his age and words but no diagnosis, actual test result, or subsequent response. The answer identifies the best communication response among these options; it does not invent an assessment finding or predict the patient’s outcome.

Sources

Эти источники подтверждают изложенные выше концепции и методы.