Political SciencePolitical Participation

Prospective Voting: Assumptions and U.S. Reality in 2015

Answer Robertson's 2015 study-guide question about future policy choices, each voter assumption, and turnout, using the contemporary classroom account.

Question

Political Science 1100, Robertson, Spring 2015Study Guide for Exam 2, Monday March 9, 2015Study-guide instructions: The best answers will be clear and concise explanations that demonstrate that you know the material. Define the key terms, use these terms accurately and include specific examples.2. Describe “prospective” voting, according to class? What does prospective voting assume about the voters? Does actual voting in the U.S. meet the assumptions of the prospective voting model? You should discuss turnout, in addition to each of the assumptions.

1. What is prospective voting?

Prospective voting is choosing a candidate by the future policies or outcomes the voter expects and prefers. For example, a voter comparing two candidates' proposed transit policies and choosing the preferred future plan would be voting prospectively. This example illustrates the model; it is not a report of an observed voter.

2. What does the classroom model assume?

Robertson's February 2015 lecture states three assumptions:

  1. Voters are well informed.
  2. Voters carefully consider several candidates.
  3. Voters choose the candidate expected to do what they think is best.

3. Does actual U.S. voting meet each assumption?

The lecture presents the model as an ideal rather than a complete description of actual elections.

AssumptionEvaluation in the 2015 classroom account
Well-informed votersCandidate images and party identification can influence choice; the account does not establish that all voters have detailed policy information.
Careful comparisonParty attachment or a candidate's image can guide choice without a full comparison of several candidates' future programs.
Preferred future policyIssue positions can support prospective choice, but assessments of incumbents' past performance are retrospective evidence.

The lecture uses 2008 as a change election favoring challenger Obama and 2012 as an election in which Obama was the incumbent. Those are classroom illustrations of retrospective reasoning, not proof of every individual's motive.

4. What about turnout?

The lecture describes low turnout and a voting electorate that does not perfectly represent voting-age adults. Even if participants compare future policies, their choices do not necessarily represent nonparticipants' preferences. Turnout is a participation limit in addition to the three assumptions about candidate choice.

Conclusion: the 2015 account describes mixed voting motives and incomplete participation, so the prospective model is a useful ideal with limited descriptive fit.

Evidence boundary

This answer addresses the Spring 2015 study guide using Robertson's contemporary public lecture, not a teacher key or present-day voting data. The lecture supplies three assumptions and a qualitative turnout assessment; no turnout rate is invented. The transit example is illustrative. The 2008/2012 examples are the lecturer's framing and do not establish individual voter motives or a single causal explanation for election outcomes.

Sources

Эти источники подтверждают изложенные выше концепции и методы.