Question
(a) Why does an ordinary rifle recoil (kick backward) when fired?(b) The barrel of a recoilless rifle is open at both ends. Describe how Newton’s third law applies when one is fired.(c) Can you safely stand close behind one when it is fired?
(a) Why an ordinary rifle recoils
While the bullet gains forward momentum, the rifle receives a backward impulse through the interacting bullet, propellant gases, and chamber. These interactions obey Newton’s third law: each force on one body has an equal, opposite partner on the other body. The backward impulse produces recoil.
For an idealized initially stationary rifle–bullet system with negligible external impulse and with gas momentum omitted,
Here and are rifle and bullet masses; forward velocity is positive. This two-body relation explains the direction of recoil. An actual momentum balance must also include the expelled gases and any impulse from the shooter or support.
(b) How the recoilless arrangement obeys the third law
Opening a rearward exit allows material, particularly propellant gases, to carry momentum backward while the projectile carries momentum forward. Accelerating material backward gives a forward reaction on the weapon; this can balance much of the backward recoil impulse associated with forward projectile acceleration.
The third law still holds for every interaction. “Recoilless” describes reduced net recoil of the weapon; it does not remove reaction forces or require that every component have zero momentum. For the idealized isolated system,
The two outgoing momenta can approximately balance, leaving little weapon momentum. The question does not specify a design, so it does not establish which rearward component carries all of that momentum.
(c) Is standing close behind it safe?
No. Rearward discharge produces a hazardous backblast of hot, rapidly moving gases and potentially other expelled material. Reduced recoil at the weapon does not make the space behind it safe. This is a conceptual answer, not a firing procedure or a specification of a safe distance.
Evidence boundary
This page answers OpenStax University Physics Volume 1, Chapter 5, Conceptual Question 13 (a–c). The momentum relations are idealized explanations, not measured firing data. The prompt gives no weapon design or safe distance. Rearward momentum may be carried by gas or other expelled material; no particular mechanism is assumed.
Sources
Эти источники подтверждают изложенные выше концепции и методы.