MathCalculus

Knowledge guide

How the Shell Method Uses Radius, Height, and Slice Direction

Build a shell integral from slice direction, distance to the axis, and boundary differences, with a fresh example about a shifted axis.

A shell is a rotated strip

The shell method finds a solid's volume by rotating thin strips parallel to the axis of rotation. A strip becomes a cylindrical shell. Its approximate volume is circumference times height times thickness; integrating gives the exact limiting volume:

V=2π∫r h dt.V=2\pi\int r\,h\,dt.

Here tt is the coordinate used to locate a strip. The radius and height are functions of that coordinate.

Choose the slice direction from the axis

For a vertical axis x=cx=c, use vertical strips and integrate with respect to xx. The radius is the horizontal distance r(x)=∣x−c∣r(x)=|x-c|, while the height is the upper boundary minus the lower boundary.

For a horizontal axis y=cy=c, use horizontal strips and integrate with respect to yy. The radius is r(y)=∣y−c∣r(y)=|y-c|, and the shell's axial length is the right boundary minus the left boundary. Calling this length the shell height does not mean it must be vertical on the original graph.

AxisShell stripIntegration variableRadius
x=cx=cVerticalxx∣x−c∣\lvert x-c\rvert
y=cy=cHorizontalyy∣y−c∣\lvert y-c\rvert

The bounds must describe where the chosen strips exist, not simply repeat the bounds of the other coordinate.

A new example with a shifted axis

Take the region between y=2xy=2x and y=x2y=x^2, for 0≤x≤20\le x\le2, and rotate it about x=−1x=-1. The axis lies outside the region. A vertical strip produces a shell with

r=x+1,h=2x−x2.r=x+1,\qquad h=2x-x^2.

Consequently,

V=2π∫02(x+1)(2x−x2) dx=2π∫02(−x3+x2+2x) dx=2π[−x44+x33+x2]02=16π3.\begin{aligned} V&=2\pi\int_0^2(x+1)(2x-x^2)\,dx\\ &=2\pi\int_0^2(-x^3+x^2+2x)\,dx\\ &=2\pi\left[-\frac{x^4}{4}+\frac{x^3}{3}+x^2\right]_0^2\\ &=\frac{16\pi}{3}. \end{aligned}

The +1+1 in the radius comes from the distance to x=−1x=-1. It is unrelated to either curve's height.

Compare shells with washers

Washer slices are perpendicular to the axis. A washer uses π(R2−r2)\pi(R^2-r^2) as its cross-sectional area, whereas a shell uses 2πrh2\pi rh as the volume contribution per unit thickness. Choose the method whose slice lengths and bounds are easier to express; do not choose solely from the appearance of a hollow solid.

Checks that transfer to other problems

Check that the radius is a distance and that the height is nonnegative over the chosen interval. Verify that radius, height, and thickness together give cubic units. If the rotation axis passes through a region, blindly adding shells from both sides can count overlapping volume twice: first describe the solid by distinct radii or use a method that avoids overlap. A change in which curve is above the other may require separate integrals.

These checks help turn a region and an axis into a correct integral before any algebra is performed.

Related question

Apply this knowledge

Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.

Shell Method: Volume Under y = 1 − x² About the y-Axis

Sources

These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.