Two equations do two different jobs
In ideal motion about a fixed pivot, a taut inextensible string constrains a body to a circle. Tension points radially inward; displacement is instantaneously tangent to the circle. Their dot product is zero, so tension does no work. Gravity changes kinetic energy as the body changes height.
Use energy to calculate speed:
Use Newton’s second law in the inward direction to calculate tension. The expression mv²/r is the net radial force required by the motion. It is not a separate extra force.
Radial direction changes around the circle
Let θ be the string’s angle measured from the downward vertical. The height above the bottom is r(1 − cos θ). Weight’s inward radial component is −mg cos θ, hence
At the bottom, weight opposes the inward direction. At the top, it helps supply the inward force. At a side point, weight has no radial component, although its tangential component can still change the speed.
A different example: release a pendulum from rest
A 0.40 kg bob on a 1.20 m string is released from rest at 60° from the downward vertical. Ignore drag and use g = 9.80 m/s². The drop to the bottom is
Energy gives v at the bottom = √(2gΔh) = √11.76 ≈ 3.43 m/s. Radial balance then gives
This oscillating pendulum example is separate from a full-circle problem. Its bottom tension exceeds its weight even though the string does no work.
Check whether a string can complete a loop
A string can pull, but cannot push. At the top of a full loop,
Combining this with the 2r rise from bottom to top yields the ideal full-loop condition vᵦ² ≥ 5gr. Equality is the marginal case with zero top tension; a robust taut path has a larger bottom speed. In the ideal energy model tension is smallest at the top.
If a calculation demands negative string tension, the assumed circular path has failed: the string becomes slack and the body enters unconstrained motion. A rigid rod can push as well as pull, so the same nonnegative-tension condition cannot be transferred to it unchanged.
Related question
Apply this knowledge
Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.
Mechanical Energy Sample: Speed and Tension in a Vertical CircleSources
These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.