ChemistryGeneral Chemistry

Knowledge guide

Build Valid Resonance Forms with Electron and Charge Checks

Preserve atomic connectivity while moving electrons, checking octets and formal charges, and interpreting the resonance hybrid.

Resonance keeps the atoms connected the same way

Resonance forms describe different localized electron assignments for one species. Keep the atoms, sigma-bond connectivity, total electron count, and net charge unchanged. Reposition lone pairs and π electrons while respecting allowed valence. Moving a hydrogen or reconnecting atoms makes a different structure, not a resonance contributor.

A fresh example: ozone

Ozone has 18 valence electrons and two equivalent octet-satisfying contributors:

O=O+−O−⟷−O−O+=O.\mathrm{O=O^+-O^-\longleftrightarrow {^-}O-O^+=O}.

In either form, the central oxygen has one lone pair, the double-bonded terminal oxygen has two, and the single-bonded terminal oxygen has three. The charges are 0, +1, and −1 in the first form, summing to zero; the terminal assignments swap in the second.

This illustrates why charge separation is not automatically a mistake: both electron counting and octets must be satisfied. Ozone is bent; a straight text formula gives connectivity, not its bond angle.

Use four checks on every drawing

  1. Count valence electrons, adding electrons for negative ionic charge or subtracting them for positive charge.
  2. Count every bonding and nonbonding electron in the proposed drawing.
  3. Check octets for second-period atoms such as C, N, and O.
  4. Calculate formal charges and confirm their sum equals the species charge:
FC=V−Nnonbonding−12Nbonding.\mathrm{FC}=V-N_{\mathrm{nonbonding}}-\tfrac12N_{\mathrm{bonding}}.

Curved-arrow tails start at an electron pair or a bond. If a new π bond would exceed a second-period atom's octet, shift another pair at the same time.

Interpret the hybrid carefully

Contributors are not molecules switching back and forth. The actual electron distribution is delocalized. Equivalent contributors contribute equally in a simple resonance description; nonequivalent contributors need not have equal weights. Fractional average bond order is a model summary, not a claim that a bond alternates between integer orders. Lower formal-charge separation and negative charge on more electronegative atoms often favor a contributor, but octet and electron-count validity come first.

Related question

Apply this knowledge

Use the concept guide to understand the reasoning, then return to the complete question and worked answer.

Resonance Forms of the Nitrite Ion: Bonds, Lone Pairs, and Charges

Sources

These references support the core concepts and interpretation boundaries explained above.